Using cameras to investigate egg predation
Investigating Brown Rat predation of seabird eggs using camera traps and experimental nests
Environmental Research Institute, University of the Highlands and Islands, Scotland, UK
Investigating brown rat Rattus norvegicus egg predation using experimental nests and camera traps. O’Hanlon, N.J. & Lambert, M.S. 2017. European Journal of Wildlife Research. DOI: 10.1007/s10344-016-1063-4. VIEW
The Calf of Man is a small island off the southern tip of the Isle of Man. It is one of many islands around Britain where rats have been implicated in the severe decline of its breeding seabirds. During the 18th century the island held an estimated breeding population of over 30,000 Manx Shearwater Puffinus puffinus (Figure 1) – the largest colony at the time in the world. However, by the 1900s the breeding population was virtually extinct, thought to be due to the accidental introduction of Brown Rats Rattus norvegicus from a Russian shipwreck. Since 1979, localised rat baiting has occurred around the island and there has been a subsequently slow increase in breeding Manx Shearwater numbers. In 2011, tape playback surveys revealed 127 apparently occupied breeding burrows. However, this is still a long way from previous numbers, therefore Manx National Heritage sought to determine the impact of Brown Rats on the island’s seabirds as part of an eradication plan.
Figure 1 Manx Shearwater Puffinus puffinus © Manx National Heritage
One question was whether the rats on the Calf predated seabird eggs. In some cases, rats have been found not to predate intact eggs due to them not possessing the necessary skills or because they don’t recognise the eggs as food (Prieto et al. 2003). In addition, some species may be restricted on the size of eggs they can predate by their gape size (Haskell 1995, Ettel et al. 1998). To investigate this, without disturbing the island’s breeding seabirds, we headed to the island during June and July 2011 and set up automated trail cameras on baited unoccupied, experimental, nests.
Figure 2 One of the 247 chocolate wax blocks placed across the island to determine the distribution of Brown Rats © Nina O’Hanlon
To establish where to locate the experimental nests we first estimated the density and distribution of rats across the island using chocolate-flavoured wax blocks (Figure 2). Wax blocks are an effective method of determining the presence of rats as it is easy to identify the characteristic teeth marks they leave behind. Using a handheld GPS, we systematically placed 247 wax blocks across the entire island on a 100 m × 100 m grid system. We checked the blocks several times over a 17-day period, replacing any that were missing or chewed. At the end of this period we found evidence of rat teeth marks at only six locations (Figure 3), indicating that the current level of rat activity was very low and localised – potentially due to the two very cold and snowy previous winters, as well as the continued localised baiting around the island’s buildings.
Figure 3 Location of experimental nest sites (red stars) and the grid of chocolate wax blocks, to determine rat activity (open circles), across the Calf of Man. Evidence of rat activity depicted by filled yellow circles.
Once we had an indication of where the rats were distributed, twelve experimental nests were located in an area where we knew rats were present and twelve where there was no evidence of rats. To investigate different nest types and egg sizes at these locations, we set up experimental nests in unoccupied rock crevices and burrows, baiting them equally with either a domestic chicken or quail egg (Figure 4).
Figure 4 Automated camera trap set up on a crevice experimental nest © Nina O’Hanlon
In total, the automated trail cameras filmed 915 24-hour periods, recording any potential predators to the experimental nests. After trawling through the many resulting images, we found that the rats only visited cavity nests at the site where we had previously recorded evidence of rat activity (Site C). Despite visits to these cavity nests on 19 individual occasions (with 16 visits to experimental nests containing chicken eggs and three to nests containing a quail egg), there was no evidence of egg predation by the rats. In fact, the rats appeared to ignore the eggs, with only one case where we observed a rat moving a chicken egg around a cavity.
That we found no evidence of rat predation could suggest that on the Calf, at their current density, the Brown Rats may not have a negative impact on the island’s seabirds – at least in terms of egg predation. The apparent lack of interest in the baited eggs may be that the rats were unable to predate the eggs, although we did not observed them trying, and they should have been able to predate the smaller quail eggs at least. Alternatively, the low density of rats on the island could mean that there was little competition for food, with plenty of more favourable food sources available.
It is also important to consider that at higher densities, where competition for food is likely to be higher, egg predation may occur. In addition, egg predation is only one mechanism by which rats can negatively affect breeding seabirds. Rats can predate on seabird chicks and even the adults (Prieto et al. 2003, Lambert et al. 2015). They can also cause seabirds to fail through disturbing the adults, causing them to abandon their nest (Bried & Jouventin 1999). Early in the season on the Calf, a number of Razorbill Alca torda and Shags Phalacrocorax aristotelis abandoned their nests at Site C where we had recorded evidence of rat presence. Although circumstantial, it could be that the rats disturbed the adults at this location in some way, causing these birds to fail.
Subsequent to this project, during the autumn and winter of 2012-2013, Manx National Heritage started a rat eradication program on the Calf of Man. Monitoring is still on going to ensure that the island remains rat free, and which will hopefully benefit all the breeding birds on the island. In 2014, the number of occupied Manx Shearwater burrows increased to 424, which is a good start!
Bried J. & Jouventin P. 1999. Influence of breeding success on fidelity in long-lived birds: an experimental study. Journal of Avian Biology 30:392–398. VIEW
Ettel T.L., Buehler D.A. & Houston A.E. 199. Egg size and cotton rat predation. The Wilson Bulletin 110:575–578. VIEW
Haskall D.G. 1995. Forest fragmentation and nest predation: are experiments with Japanese quail eggs misleading? The Auk 112:767–770. VIEW
Lambert M., Carlisle S. & Cain I. 2015. The role of brown rat (Rattus norvegicus) predation in determining breeding success of Manx shearwaters (Puffinus puffinus) on Rum. Scottish Natural Heritage Commissioned Report 697. VIEW
Prieto J., González-Solís J., Ruiz X. & Jover L. 2003. Can rats prey on gull eggs? An experimental approach. Biodiversity Conservation 12:2477–2486. VIEW
About the author
Nina O’Hanlon is an ornithologist with a particular interest in seabird ecology and conservation. She is currently a post-doc at the Environmental Research Institute (University of Highlands and Islands), based in Thurso, Scotland, looking at the effect of plastic debris on seabirds in the Northeast Atlantic. Previously, she completed a PhD at the University of Glasgow on spatial variation in diet, egg traits and movement of Herring Gulls.
View Nina’s full profile
Follow Nina on Twitter @Nina_OHanlon
Top right: Brown rat Rattus norvegicus image from the camera trap © Nina O’Hanlon
Blog posts express the views of the individual author(s) and not those of the BOU.
If you want to write about your research in #theBOUblog, then please see here.