Home | About Us | Membership | Online Store | Conferences | The British List | Checklists | Ibis

 

Records Committee (BOURC)

24th Report (October 1997)

The reports of the Records Committee contain additions, corrections and modifications to the list of birds of Britain and Ireland maintained by the Records Committee on behalf of the BOU. This report covers the period July 1996 to September 1997 and is the eighth to follow publication of the most recent Checklist of Birds of Britain and Ireland (6th edition, March 1992). The 23rd Report appeared in Ibis 139: 197-201. The Checklist is available from the BOU office and specialist bookshops, price £4.95 (+ £1 p&p).

The following changes have been made to the British List:

Redhead Aythya americana (Eyton)
Add to category A.
Male, Bleasby, Nottinghamshire, 8-27 March 1996; sight record; photographed (Birding World 9: 93-97). Monotypic. The species breeds chiefly in the prairies of western Canada south to California and Nebraska. It winters from British Columbia and the Great Lakes to central Mexico and Cuba. A previous record from Sweden is now believed to be a hybrid (Var Vagelvarld 43: 549).

Pallid Harrier Circus macrourus
Change to category A.
Male, near Aberfeldy, Perth & Kinross, 5-7 May 1993, sight record. The first accepted record since 1952. Previously in category B (Ibis 134: 212). There was a notable influx to NW Europe in 1993 (Brit. Birds 87: 4; 88: 268).

American Coot Fulica americana
Add to category A.
Possibly first-summer, Stodmarsh, Kent, 16-29 or 30 April 1996; sight record; photographed (Birding World 9: 137-140). Added to category A of the British list, though the species has previously occurred in Ireland at Ballycotton, Co. Cork, from 7 February to 4 April 1981 (Ibis 126: 440; Irish Birds 2: 192-194; Brit. Birds 77: 12-16).

Kumlien's Gull Larus glaucoides kumlieni
Third-winter female, Shetland, 24 November 1869. Specimen in the Natural History Museum, Tring (BMHN 1879.11.10.11; Brit. Birds 88: 23). This predates the current earliest accepted record from Penzance, Cornwall, March 1979 (Ibis 137: 590).

Blyth's Pipit Anthus godlewskii
Skewjack, Cornwall, 22 October to at least 1 November 1990; trapped; photographed (Birding World 3: 375-378). This predates the current earliest accepted recent record from Landguard, Suffolk, in November 1994 (Ibis 139: 198), though the first record dates from 1882 in East Sussex (Ibis 122: 565).

Cedar Waxwing Bombycilla cedrorum Vieillot
Add to category A.
Noss, Shetland, 25-26 June 1985 (Ibis 135: 221); Nottingham from 20 February - 18 March 1996; sight records; photographed (Birding World 9: 70-73). The record from Noss has been reconsidered in the light of a bird in Iceland from April to July 1989 and the Nottingham bird. Additional information was uncovered relating to movements and abundance in northeast North America in 1985 and on the strength of this, the Noss bird has been upgraded from category D to A.
Monotypic. Breeds across much of northern United States of America and southern Canada, the population moving southwards to winter down into Mexico. It was formerly quite common in captivity, but became less available after the Mexican ban on exports became effective in the mid to late 1980s.

Dark-throated Thrush Turdus ruficollis
Add nominate subspecies to category A.
First-winter male, Walton on the Naze, Essex from 29 September to 7 October 1994; sight record; photographed (Birding World 7: 392-395). Black-throated T. r. atrogularis and Red-throated Thrushes T. r. ruficollis are still regarded as conspecific, although increasing field work in the area of contact may lead to this view being revised. The nominate race which breeds in east Siberia migrates through Mongolia and China west to Sinkiang and Tibet to winter in Afghanistan, northern Pakistan, northern Kashmir to Assam, northern Burma, and north and west China.

Hume's Leaf Warbler Phylloscopus humei (Brooks)
Add to category A.
Beachy Head, East Sussex, 14-17 November 1966; sight record (Brit. Birds 72: 124-5). Subsequent records under review by BBRC. This species was split from P. inornatus in 1997 (Ibis 139: 198). Nominate humei breeds in central Asia from the Sayan and Altai mountains south to the northwest Himalayas, and winters mainly in the Indian subcontinent from Pakistan to Bangladesh.

Eastern Bonelli's Warbler Phylloscopus orientalis (C. L. Brehm)
Add to category A.
St Mary's, Scilly, 8-10 October 1987; Whitley Bay, Tyne & Wear, 20-29 September 1995; sight records; Whitley Bay bird photographed. Monotypic. This species was split from P. bonelli in 1997 (Ibis 139: 198). A long-distance migrant, it breeds from the Balkans eastwards through Turkey, and winters in East Africa.

Bay-breasted Warbler Dendroica castanea (Wilson)
Add to category A.
Lands End, Cornwall, 1 October 1995; sight record; video (Brit. Birds in press). Monotypic. A long-distance migrant breeding across northern N. America in a belt from eastern British Columbia through the northern Great Lakes to New England, and wintering in tropical America from Panama to Colombia and Venezuela.

Black-faced Bunting Emberiza spodocephala Pallas
Add to category A.
First-winter male, Pennington Flash, Greater Manchester, 8 March - 24 April 1994; trapped and photographed (Brit. Birds in press). Nominate race. Nominate spodocephala breeds from the Ob to the Sea of Okhotsk south to northern Tibet, Manchuria and N. Korea. It migrates through Mongolia, southeast Russia, northeast China and Korea to winter in southern Korea, eastern and southern China to Kwangsi and Hunan, also in Taiwan.

The following have also been considered

Red-tailed Hawk Buteo jamaicensis
Specimen in the Natural History Museum, Tring (BMNH 1939.12.9.3588) said to have been obtained in Kirkwall, Orkney on 16 March 1919. The identification is accepted, but the stated origin must be doubtful, given the specimen's provenance from the collection of Sir Vauncey Harpur Crewe.

South Polar Skua Catharacta maccormicki
Specimen in Norwich Castle Museum (NCM 74.23), said to have been obtained at Yarmouth, Norfolk in 1869 (Sea Swallow 43: 74-76). Identification accepted but its origin in British waters is unproven, though possible.

Desert Lark Ammomanes deserti
Found dead on the beach at Minsmere, Suffolk, 2 April 1997, specimen deposited at NHM, Tring. Race uncertain, possibly payni. Circumstances suggested the specimen may not have arrived naturally.

Chestnut Bunting Emberiza rutila
Adult female, Out Skerries, Shetland, 2-5 September 1994. Identification accepted but the species is still commonly imported and no case was found for upgrading from category D.

The decisions reported here increase the number of species on the British and the British & Irish lists to 557 and 551, respectively. These totals do not include "soft-plumaged" petrel Pterodroma mollis/P. madeira/P. feae, as the birds were not identified to species level (Ibis 134: 180). Those species only in Category D do not form part of the main list.

Category

Britain

Britain & Ireland

A

527

534

B

15

14

C

9

9

D

20

20

Total

551

557

The following category A species have occurred in Ireland, but not in Britain: Ruddy Shelduck Tadorna ferruginea, Bald Eagle Haliaeetus leucocephalus, Short-billed Dowitcher Limnodromus griseus, Elegant Tern Sterna elegans, Grey Catbird Dumetella carolinensis, Fox Sparrow Passerella iliaca, Indigo Bunting Passerina cyanea.

Files under consideration (with date of receipt from BBRC):

Greater Flamingo Phoenicopterus ruber
Review of migration and movements to assess likelihood of natural vagrancy from both western and eastern populations (new BOURC file - July 1997).

Bufflehead Bucephala albeola
Review of records following submission of evidence that the first British record from Norfolk in 1830 may be unsafe (new BOURC file - July 1996).

Egyptian Vulture Neophron percnopterus
Beaulieu Road Station, Hampshire, 16 June 1968 (rec. November 1994)

Accepted records from Bridgwater Bay, Somerset (October 1825) and Peldon, Essex (September 1868) are also being assessed as part of the review of all species currently in Category B. File is being re-circulated with additional information.

Little Tern Sterna albifrons antillarum
Rye Harbour, E. Sussex, many dates between 1983 and 1993, also Colne Point, Essex, 29 June - 1 July 1991 (rec. July 1994). See Ibis 139: 200.

Olivaceous Warbler Hippolais pallida
Isle of May, Fife, 24-26 September 1967 (rec. April 1995). Also review of earlier records. File in circulation.

Booted Warbler Hippolais caligata rama
Lerwick, Shetland, 22 October - 9 November 1993 (rec. April 1995). File in circulation.

Booted Warbler Hippolais caligata annectens
Theddlethorpe Dunes, Lincolnshire, 12 October 1980 (rec. April 1995). File in circulation.

Chaffinch Fringilla coelebs africana / F. c. spodiogenys
Fingringhoe, Essex, 9-25 April 1994. Circulation complete; file returned to BBRC.

Indigo Bunting Passerina cyanea
Ramsey Island, Pembrokeshire, 1st-winter male, 18-26 October 1996 (rec. May 1997). File in circulation.

Publications from members of the BOU Records Committee relating to the British & Irish list since the last Report (Ibis 139: 200).
  • Parkin, D. T. 1996. (Comments on "Mourning Dove in the Isle of Man: new to the Western Palearctic" by A. Sapsford.) Brit. Birds 89: 157-161.
  • Parkin, D. T. 1996. (Comments on "Double-crested in Cleveland: new to the Western Palearctic" by T. J. Williams.) Brit. Birds 89: 162-170.
  • Parkin, D. T. 1996. (Comments on "Northern Mockingbirds in Britain" by P. R. Cobb, P. Rawnsley, H. E. Grenfell, E. Griffiths & S. Cox.) Brit. Birds 89: 347-356.
  • Parkin, D. T. 1997. OrnithoNews: European committees meeting. Birding World 10: 242.
Lists and categorisation

At the 1995 BOU conference at Peterborough (Holmes & Simons 1996. The Introduction and Naturalisation of Birds London, HMSO), it became apparent that it was necessary to improve the recording of non-native birds in Great Britain and Northern Ireland to assist the governmental agencies with their legislative responsibilities. As a result of this, the last two years have seen a major review of categorisation within the British List by the BOURC, and the accumulation of hundreds of records of escaped, non-native species that have been recorded at large in the countryside. After consultation with the Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC), it also became apparent that the different legal systems in the two areas of Great Britain and Northern Ireland required separate lists to help the national agencies with their wild bird legislation. Consequently, in future, lists for both of these areas will be published in Ibis, with a combined list for Great Britain & Northern Ireland to replace the British & Irish List that has been published up until now. Full details of the categories will be published in the next Report, together with revised totals, and an explanatory paper is currently in preparation for British Birds. It is gratifying that government agencies such as JNCC look to the Union and its Records Committee when considering the status of birds, and their conservation and protection under national wildlife legislation.

Association of European Rarities Committees

In July 1997, Alan Knox and David Parkin attended the fourth meeting of the Association of European Rarities Committees (AERC) at Blahova in the Slovak Republic. A decision was taken to review the taxonomic status of the birds of the West Palaearctic. A great deal of research is underway in Europe (and beyond) into the phylogenetics of birds, and a subcommittee was delegated to examine this over the next two years. It will attempt to produce a taxonomy for the AERC list of European birds. This is a major undertaking, as it will include both intra- and supra-specific relationships. Marrying together the philosophies of the phylogenetic and biological species concepts, and incorporating contemporary research in zoogeography, behaviour, morphology, acoustics and molecular biology is a challenging task. However, it is recognised that avian taxonomy is going through an exciting phase, and that European ornithologists should work together towards this common goal.

Acknowledgements

As always, we are very grateful for the observers for providing details of many of these birds. Other people help the Committee with individual records, and in particular we thank Per Alstršm, Peter Barthel, Dr Bill Bourne, Colin R Casey, Bill Clark, Lee Evans, Dick Forsman, Paul Herroelen, Tim Inskipp, Dr Tony Irwin, Bruce Mactavish, Bob McGowan, Dr John Richards, Dr Kees Roselaar, Hadoram Shirihai, Drs Arnoud van den Berg, Doug Weir, Geoff & Hilary Welch and Frank Woolham.

The Committee is grateful to Michael Rogers, Secretary of the British Birds Rarities Committee, for assistance with the preparation of files, and his continuous good humour in the face of interminable questions and correspondence relating to the deliberations of his Committee. We thank the members of BBRC for their valuable comments on matters of identification, and also Paul Milne, Secretary of Irish Rare Birds Committee, for his assistance with several records. We are also grateful to The Natural History Museum, Tring for granting us access to skins & the library, and Dr Robert Prys-Jones, Mark Adams, Don Smith, Cyril Walker, Michael Walters and Effie Warr for facilitating our researches there.

The following served as members of the Committee during the period covered by the report (expected year of retirement in brackets). 1997 marked the final year of service for John Marchant who retires under rotation. The Committee wishes to record its gratitude to John, particularly for his work with the ÔIntroduced Birds Working GroupÕ, and for his efforts in initiating a database of escapes. He will be replaced on Records Committee by Dr Roger Wilkinson, Curator of Birds at Chester Zoo.

  • Dr D. T. Parkin (Chairman) (1998)
  • I. K. Dawson (Secretary) (2005)
  • P. V. Harvey (2004)
  • R. A. Hume (Chairman, BBRC, ex-officio)
  • Dr A. G. Knox (2003)
  • J. H. Marchant (1997)
  • B. A. E. Marr (2000)
  • R. F. Porter (2001)
  • K. D. Shaw (2002)
  • K. E. Vinicombe (1999)
  • Dr R. Wilkinson (2006)

British Ornithologists' Union Records Committee
c/o The Natural History Museum, Tring, Herts HP23 6AP, UK
Email: bourc.sec@bou.org.uk

back to top

           

The BOU is a Registered Charity in the UK, no. 249877